How Personal Injury Settlements Are Different from Jury Verdicts in Georgia

How Personal Injury Settlements Are Different from Jury Verdicts in Georgia

/by

When pursuing a personal injury claim in Georgia, one of the most important decisions you will face is whether to accept a settlement or take your case to trial. Both paths come with their own set of benefits and risks. Settlements offer a quicker, more predictable outcome, sparing you the time and expense of a trial. Jury verdicts, on the other hand, can potentially result in a larger award, though they are uncertain and can extend the legal process significantly. An experienced Georgia personal injury lawyer can help you weigh your options and decide the best course of action for your case.

What are the Differences Between Settlements and Jury Verdicts in Georgia?

In Georgia, personal injury claims can be resolved through either a settlement or a jury verdict. Each option has its own unique process and outcome. Understanding these differences can help you determine the best path for your case.

How a Settlement Works

A settlement occurs when both parties agree on a compensation amount without going to trial. This negotiation typically involves you, your lawyer, and the insurance company representing the at-fault party. Settlements can be reached at any point during the legal process – before filing a lawsuit, during pre-trial negotiations, or during the course of the trial, before a verdict is reached.

Pros of a Settlement

  • Faster resolution: Settlements can conclude much sooner than a trial, often providing much-needed financial relief more quickly.
  • Predictable outcome: By negotiating a settlement, you have control over the final amount, rather than leaving it in the hands of a jury.
  • Lower costs: Trials can be expensive due to court fees and legal expenses. Settling typically reduces these costs.
  • Less stress: Settling avoids the emotional toll and uncertainty of a trial.

Cons of a Settlement

  • Potentially lower compensation: Settlements are often lower than what a jury might award, especially in cases involving severe injuries.
  • Finality: Once a settlement is accepted, you cannot seek additional compensation, even if any injury-related medical issues arise in the future.

How a Jury Verdict Works

A jury verdict is the result of a trial where both sides present their evidence and arguments before a jury. Based on the case facts and evidence presented, the jury will decide if the at-fault party is liable. If they are found liable, the jury will determine how much compensation should be awarded. The trial process includes discovery, depositions, pre-trial motions, and courtroom hearings. This process can take months or even years to reach a conclusion.

Pros of a Jury Verdict

  • Potential for higher compensation: A jury might award more than what the at-fault party’s insurance company was willing to offer in a settlement. This occurs particularly in cases involving serious injuries or gross negligence.
  • Accountability: A jury verdict can hold the at-fault party publicly accountable for their actions, which might be important in cases of gross negligence or misconduct.

Cons of a Jury Verdict

  • Uncertainty: Juries are unpredictable. Even if you have a strong case, there is no guarantee that the jury will rule in your favor or award you the amount you expect.
  • Lengthy process: Trials can take a long time, especially with the back-and-forth of legal procedures, which can delay the receipt of compensation.
  • Higher costs: Going to trial typically involves more legal fees and court costs, which can reduce your net recovery.
  • Stressful experience: Trials are public, emotionally taxing, and require more time and involvement from the injured party.

When Should I Consider Going to Trial?

While settlements are faster, less stressful, and significantly cheaper than pursuing litigation, there are certain circumstances where going to trial might be necessary. These include: 

Low Settlement Offers 

If the at-fault party’s insurance company offers a settlement that is far lower than what you believe your claim is worth, and if they stubbornly refuse to reconsider their offer, a trial might be necessary to get fair compensation. 

Severe Injuries or Long-Term Consequences 

If your injuries are severe or permanent, you may require substantial compensation. The insurance company might not be willing to offer this amount. A jury, on the other hand, may be more sympathetic to your plight. They are more likely to award sufficient damages to compensate you for the full extent of your injuries and long-term consequences.

Disputed liability 

If the at-fault party denies responsibility for the accident, going to trial might be your only option. In such cases, presenting evidence to a jury might be the only way to establish fault and liability and get the compensation you deserve. 

Punitive Damages 

In cases involving gross negligence, reckless behavior, or intentional harm, you can take your case to trial and seek punitive damages in addition to compensation for your losses. Punitive damages are intended to punish the at-fault party and deter similar behavior in the future. If the jury finds the at-fault party’s conduct particularly egregious, you might be awarded substantial compensation including compensatory as well as punitive damages. 

The Need for Accountability 

If the at-fault party’s actions were particularly egregious and you want to hold them publicly accountable, a trial can provide a platform for that. This might be especially important in cases involving drunk driving, medical malpractice, or intentional harm.

Settlement vs. Trial – How a Georgia Personal Injury Lawyer Can Help You Decide 

Deciding whether to accept a settlement or go to trial is a complex and personal choice that depends on the facts of your case. An experienced Georgia personal injury lawyer can analyze your case and help you weigh the pros and cons of each option. Your lawyer will evaluate factors such as:

  • The strength of your evidence
  • The amount of compensation being offered in a settlement
  • The costs and time associated with going to trial
  • The potential for a higher award if the case goes to trial
  • The unpredictability of a jury’s decision

After assessing these factors and the unique circumstances of your case, your lawyer can help you make an informed decision about whether it is worth taking your case to trial.

The Importance of Choosing a Trial Lawyer to Represent You

When pursuing a personal injury claim, choosing a lawyer with extensive litigation experience is critical to the success of your case. A trial lawyer, who is skilled in both negotiations and courtroom proceedings, can make a significant difference in the outcome of your claim.

Leverage in Settlement Negotiations

Having a trial lawyer represent you can be a powerful tool in settlement negotiations. They can anticipate the tactics that the insurance company might use to minimize the payout. This allows them to push back with confidence and negotiate from a position of strength.

During the course of the negotiations, the lawyer can highlight the strengths of your claim and make it clear to the other party that a trial might not go in their favor. This potential threat of litigation often encourages insurers to settle on more favorable terms in order to avoid the time and costs of a trial.

Trial Readiness

While most personal injury cases are settled out of court, some disputes cannot be resolved through negotiation alone. In these situations, it’s essential to have a lawyer who is fully prepared to take your case to trial. 

An experienced trial lawyer knows what kind of evidence will stand up in court and how to use it. They know how to present your case persuasively, handle complex legal arguments, and cross-examine witnesses effectively. This level of trial readiness can be crucial in securing a favorable verdict if your case goes to court.

Courtroom Experience

Choosing a lawyer with extensive litigation experience ensures that you have an advocate who is comfortable in the courtroom. A trial lawyer is not intimidated by the prospect of facing a jury.  They thrive in situations that require quick thinking, strong communication, and the ability to adapt to unexpected developments.

Choose a Fighter with Extensive Litigation Experience to Handle Your Georgia Personal Injury Claim

If you have been injured due to someone else’s negligence, Georgia personal injury lawyer Tanya Miller is ready to fight for you. She aims to secure the compensation you deserve. With a background as a former prosecutor and criminal defense attorney, Tanya has thousands of hours of courtroom experience. She brings a wealth of legal knowledge to the table, giving you a unique advantage in your case. 

Call our firm today at 855-44MILLER or contact us online for a free consultation with one of our diligent Georgia personal injury lawyers.